jcoffey-dev is traveling from Thursday 1 October through Sunday 4 October. Issues and pull requests are welcome, and will get an answer after that. Thanks for your patience.
What administrators and the server itself do to the control plane is now
recorded, from inbuxa-drafts/specs/audit-hold-lock.md (AU-1 to AU-12):
settings, accounts, domains, roles and every other registry change, with
each field's before and after (secrets only as "changed"); the fork's own
settings objects; administrator sign-ins (and failed ones to administrator
accounts), master-user and recovery-admin sign-ins, once an hour per
account, method and address; access to another account's data through
impersonation or FetchAnyBlob, once an hour; exports and tamper checks;
and registry writes the server makes on its own, named by subsystem
(system:AcmeRenewal, system:auto-ban, system:directory-sync, ...), with a
spam rules update as one summary record.
No change without its record (AU-3): before a set method changes anything,
a pending record per requested create, update and destroy is written; if
that fails, the method is refused with serverFail. Its outcome follows as
a later entry. A change interrupted by a crash stays "unfinished".
Records live in the fork's subspace under L, as one SHA-256 hash chain per
node. The chain's head is stored, never cached, and every append asserts
it, so two writers can't take the same place. Nothing can edit or delete
a record; the daily purge removes the oldest past the retention (default
730 days, minimum 90) and records where the chain now starts, so
verification still passes. security.audit-recorded (647) copies each
record to webhooks, OpenTelemetry and the log; security.audit-write-failed
(648) reports a failed write.
New JMAP objects under urn:inbuxa:jmap: inbuxa:AuditEvent/get and /query
(filters: time, actor, action, target, account, tenant, outcome, address,
text), inbuxa:AuditSettings, inbuxa:AuditExport (CSV or JSON Lines built
on the server, each line with its chain hash, ending in a manifest; the
created object names the blob and its SHA-256) and
inbuxa:AuditVerification. New permissions sysAuditGet, sysAuditExport and
sysAuditSettingsUpdate: the Administrator role gets all three, the Tenant
Administrator role gets read and export, once, on existing installs too.
A tenant administrator sees records whose actor or target is in its
tenant, including a server administrator's changes there.
Sign-in method on the session: access tokens now remember how they signed
in (password, app password, API key, OAuth client, directory, master user,
recovery admin), including across the HTTP credential cache. New OAuth
access tokens carry their client id in the sealed claims; older ones show
as client "unknown" until they expire.
The schema gains the permissions, the two events and a Management >
Compliance > Audit Log link.
Stack: the request layer boxes every inner future where it's made. Without
that, a debug build overflowed the default 2 MB worker stack on a registry
set; measured with the same request, the branch and main now overflow at
the same stack size (between 1856 and 1920 KiB, debug), so the layer adds
nothing measurable.
Tests: unit tests in inbuxa-features and jmap; system::audit::audit_log_tests
(run with --ignored) passes on RocksDB, SQLite, PostgreSQL, PostgreSQL with a
read replica, MySQL, MySQL with a replica and FoundationDB. The system, JMAP
and SCIM suites pass. authorization.rs skipped fork permissions that guard
no registry object; the audit suite checks a plain user is refused instead.
A cluster rehearsal sent ten x:<Object>/set requests at once and got
ten full reloads on every node. #39's coalescing only joined writes
that queued behind a running reload, but the requests reached the
server about 33 ms apart and a reload takes tens of milliseconds, so
none overlapped one.
A full reload after a registry write now waits for writes to settle:
75 ms after the last one, and at most 250 ms after the first it
covers, so a steady stream still reloads at least four times a
second. 75 ms is a little over twice the gap the rehearsal saw between
requests. A single write pays it once: in the tests a settings write
takes about 140 ms instead of 60. The reload runs in a task of its
own, so a request that goes away doesn't cancel it for the others.
Each write takes the result of the first reload that started after it
was stored (the gate keeps the last 64 results), so applied true or
false still describes the reload that covered that write.
The 33 ms gap was a queue on the server, not password hashing: Basic
credentials are cached per Authorization header, so they are checked
once. Every authenticated HTTP request counted itself against the
account's rate limit by incrementing one counter per account in the
in-memory store, so parallel requests from one account queued on that
key: a row lock on PostgreSQL (a few round trips to the database
each) and conflict retries with a 50-300 ms backoff on RocksDB. An
account with the unlimitedRequests permission (administrators, by
default) passes the rate and concurrency limits anyway, so its
requests are no longer counted. Ten parallel Core/echo calls as the
admin now finish in 1-4 ms; before, they finished one after another
over 20 ms on a local PostgreSQL and 300-450 ms on RocksDB. Other
accounts still count every request.
system::auto_reload::settings_reload_tests: ten concurrent writes now
take one reload (the gate counts them; at most two allowed), all are
applied: true and in the running settings, and a single write takes
exactly one reload. RocksDB and PostgreSQL, 1 reload in 141-196 ms.
With the old behavior (no wait, requests counted) the same writes
took 5 reloads; without the wait but with the rate fix, 2.
cluster::broadcast (3 nodes, PostgreSQL + NATS) and system::reload
still pass.
In cluster rehearsal 3, turning outboundMta off on node1's role was
reported applied (x:settingsReload applied: true), yet node1 kept
delivering mail, a report message included, until it was restarted.
The queue and report managers were started at boot only when the
node's role included outboundMta (crates/smtp/src/lib.rs), and the task
manager only when the role had some task type (spawn_task_manager).
After that nothing looked at the role again: a queue manager that was
running kept claiming and delivering, and one that wasn't never
started.
They now start on every node (outside recovery mode) and follow the
role live:
- Queue manager: before each scan it reads the role from the running
settings. Without outboundMta it claims nothing new; deliveries
already running finish and report back as usual, which releases
their locks. When the role comes back (a reload wakes the manager
with ReloadSettings, and it looks again every 30 s regardless) it
logs queue.started and scans the whole queue at once.
- Report scheduler: DMARC and TLS report events are handled only while
the role has outboundMta, as at boot; events arriving without it are
dropped, as they were on a node started without the role.
- Task manager: task_enabled already read the current role on every
scan. It now also runs on nodes whose role has no task type (the
scan returns at once until one is added), a job claimed before a
role change is handed back at once rather than run or held until
its lease lapses, and a settings reload wakes the manager so a role
that gained task types starts claiming them straight away.
Starting the queue manager on every node also drains the queue channel
on nodes without outboundMta. Upstream left that channel unread, so
each message queued there parked a refresh in it, and by the code,
queueing would block once 1024 had piled up (not reproduced here).
A role object edit reaches the nodes that name that role in
INBUXA_ROLE. Moving a node to another role still means changing its
environment, and so a restart. Listener changes in a role still need a
restart too (listeners bind at boot); this change is about tasks and
delivery.
cluster::live_roles::live_role_tests (new; PostgreSQL, two nodes over
one store):
1. A node started with outboundMta delivers and runs a TLS report
task; after its role loses outboundMta and the settings reload, a
new message isn't attempted and a new report task stays pending;
with the role back, both are taken up.
2. A node started with no task type at all gains outboundMta: a
waiting message is attempted and a report task runs.
On main the test fails at step 1 ("delivery attempted without
outboundMta"); with step 1 bypassed, step 2 fails (nothing picked the
message up in 20 s).
write_reload_target sent AllowedIp writes to the blocked-IP reload, but
that reload rebuilds only BlockedIps. Allowed IPs are parsed into the
core's security settings (Security::parse), which only a full reload
rebuilds, so an AllowedIp write reported x:settingsReload applied: true
while the change wasn't live until the next full reload.
AllowedIp now maps to the full reload, like the other settings objects;
BlockedIp keeps its targeted reload.
system::auto_reload::settings_reload_tests now creates an allowed IP
over JMAP and checks that is_ip_allowed sees it with no ReloadSettings,
and that destroying it takes it out again. On main it fails ("allowed
IP not in the running settings").
A 3-node rehearsal found that saving an MtaDeliverySchedule left it
unknown to the queue ("Queue strategy not found") until someone ran
x:Action ReloadSettings; only Directory and Authentication writes
reloaded (DIR-17). The admin UI has to remember a separate reload after
every save, and a script or API client that doesn't gets a server
running stale settings.
x:<Object>/set now reloads the running settings when it created,
updated or destroyed an object they are built from, and broadcasts the
same RegistryChange::Reload over the coordinator as ReloadSettings, so
every node applies it:
- Settings objects (MTA, spam filter, listeners, tracers, Sieve system
scripts, cluster roles, directories, ...: the object types the core,
telemetry, listener and directory builders read) get a full reload.
- Certificates, lookup stores and blocked/allowed IPs get their own
targeted reloads.
- Accounts, domains, roles and other data read as needed, stores (they
take a restart) and applications (their own reload action) get none.
Full reloads are coalesced: a write waits for a reload that started
after it was stored and joins one if it can, so a burst of writes, or
a request with many objects, costs one or two reloads, not one each.
The write itself is never undone. When the reload is refused (build
errors in objects that were working, the rule from the previous
commit), the set response says so in a new x:settingsReload field,
{"applied": false, "description": "Saved, but the running settings
were not reloaded. <object>: <error>"}; {"applied": true} otherwise.
The field is absent when the write needs no reload. The description
helper is shared with ReloadSettings' refusal.
Each reload sends the queue a ReloadSettings event, so the SMTP test
harness's read_event, try_read_event and assert_no_events now pass over
those; expect_reload_settings still waits for one.
system::auto_reload::settings_reload_tests (new): an MtaVirtualQueue
and an MtaDeliverySchedule created over JMAP are in the running
settings with no ReloadSettings, and gone once destroyed; eight
concurrent creates all land; a write whose reload fails is stored and
reported applied: false with the error; a domain write carries no
x:settingsReload. On main the new schedule is missing. The cluster
broadcast test (three nodes, PostgreSQL + NATS) now checks that every
node has a schedule created on node 0 without a reload.
A 3-node rehearsal found every settings reload refused, cluster-wide,
because one node couldn't resolve the Pyzor server:
- PyzorConfig::parse resolved the host while building the settings and
made a failed lookup a build error. It now keeps the host and port and
resolves when a message is checked (an IP address is used as is, a
name is reused for five minutes, the lookup counts against the Pyzor
timeout). A failure there is a Pyzor error for that message.
- A milter's hostname was resolved the same way, with a blocking
to_socket_addrs in async code. An IP address is kept; a name is now
resolved on each connection.
Other build-time I/O is already non-fatal: directories that can't
connect become unavailable with a warning (DIR-21), and the AI model
locality check only warns.
reload_registry swapped the core only when the whole build was free of
errors, while boot runs with whatever built. One failing object thus
refused every later reload, and the running settings went stale. Now a
reload is refused only for errors in objects that built when the
running settings were built (at boot or by the last applied reload):
applying it would lose those. Objects that already failed then are
missing from the running settings anyway, as at boot, so their errors
are logged and returned as known_errors but don't hold the reload back.
Refusing on new errors keeps a bad edit from taking a working object
out of service; the admin gets the error instead.
ReloadSettings now says "Settings were not reloaded." and names the
object and its error ("Tracer with id ...: Only one console tracer is
allowed"), with a count of any further errors. A refused reload after a
directory change logs its errors too.
system::reload::reload_tests (new): with Pyzor enabled on an
unresolvable host, ReloadSettings succeeds (on main it fails with
"Invalid address: failed to lookup address information"); an IP host
needs no lookup; a new build error refuses the reload, names the object
and leaves the running settings unchanged; the same error, once known
from the running settings' build, no longer blocks; once fixed, a new
error there blocks again. smtp::inbound::milter's session test now
names its milter "localhost", so the connect-time lookup is exercised.
The AGPL asks a modified version to carry prominent notices saying it was
modified, and giving a date. Publishing the source is the conveyance that
asks for it, so it wants doing before the repository is public rather than
at the release.
Every upstream file the fork changed now says so in its header, beneath the
notice it came with: 164 files, found by diffing against the upstream
snapshot branch rather than by guessing, so the list is what actually
differs. Files the fork wrote itself already carry their own copyright and
need nothing. Upstream's notices are untouched, which its licence requires
and which was already true.
The README says the same thing in prose, since the obligation is on the
work as a whole and not only its Rust files.
Builds unchanged: the server and the test binary both compile.
Every one of the 14 was `#[cfg(not(feature = "enterprise"))]` on the arm the
fork always compiles: the Enterprise arms went with the import, and nothing
turns the feature on. Removing the attribute leaves the same code, now
unconditional, in 11 files.
Two of them looked like behavior worth checking before touching: the
`validate_tenant_quota` stub that always passes, and the refusal to cancel a
pending DestroyAccount task. The stub is vestigial — the rebuilt
multi-tenancy enforces quotas in `crates/features/src/tenancy/quota.rs` for
those objects and more — and the refusal is undelete's open question, which
this change leaves exactly as it was.
The binary builds with no new warnings, and `system_tests` and `jmap_tests`,
which cover the touched registry, task-manager and auth paths, both pass.
The feature definitions stay in the manifests, inert: taking them out would
widen every sync's diff for nothing.
`allowScimProvisioning` is cached with the domain as DOMAIN_FLAG_SCIM, but
it wasn't among the fields whose change drops the cached entry, so flipping
the flag changed nothing until something else evicted the domain. SCIM-60
says the change takes effect without a restart.
Found by the two acceptance checks that were written but never called from
the driver, so neither had ever run: `authority` (SCIM-58 to SCIM-60,
through `synchronize_account` itself) and `rate_limits` (SCIM-14). Both are
wired in now, and `scim_tests` passes with them.
The two lookups every caller uses now honor Domain.directoryId, then the
server default, then the internal directory, so sign-in, bearer routing,
recipient lookup, discovery, the PACC record and the refusal of password
changes on external accounts all follow the domain. A directoryId, or a
server default, naming a directory that doesn't exist is unavailable,
never the internal directory.
A directory speaks only for the domains it serves: an account it returns
on another directory's domain is refused, for sign-in and recipients
alike, and aliases and group claims on such domains are dropped with a
warning. A bearer token must belong to the user the client names, or the
name must be one of its aliases with alias sign-in allowed. Accounts and
groups that sync creates pass the tenant checks, limits included.
On such a domain, sign-in sync creates no account (the person gets an
ordinary authentication failure), changes nothing on an existing one,
and creates no group from a groups claim. Without the flag sync works as
before, and turning it off hands accounts back to sync with no restart.
Checked through synchronize_account itself; acceptance test 5 does the
same over OIDC once per-domain directories exist.
Every SCIM operation becomes the x:Account get, query or set JMAP makes,
as the service principal, so permissions, tenant scope and limits,
address uniqueness and account destruction are enforced in one place.
Discovery is anonymous; everything else takes an API key as a bearer
token and nothing else. Domains open to SCIM carry a flag in the domain
cache. Filters take eq and and, answered from the account indexes, with
unindexed attributes checked on at most 200 candidates. Cursors are
stateless, HMAC-sealed under the server key. PATCH applies to the
resource in memory and saves it as a PUT, so it is all or nothing.
Groups get an address from their display name on the principal's
domain; membership is written on each user.
Every write emits one of five new scim.* events (ids 637 to 641), also
added to the packaged schema. The helpers the surviving SCIM suites
import are rebuilt from the spec; scim_tests runs the new acceptance
suite and the surviving tenant isolation suite, and both pass.
Every node writes a sample per metric on metricsCollectionInterval:
counters as the increase since its last sample, gauges always, histograms
as totals when changed. Samples are x:Metric in the registry's encoding
under the telemetry key class, ids time-ordered. x:Metric/get and /query
read them with metric and timestamp filters and full paging, hide what's
past holdMetricsFor, and the data purge deletes it. The is_enterprise
split is gone, so every gauge and histogram is collected and exported, and
queue.count is set from the queue itself. The shared metrics suite runs.
A live mask accepts mail at RCPT TO and delivers to its owner, with an
X-Masked-Email header naming it. A disabled mask files straight to Trash,
past the owner's Sieve script. Deleted and expired masks are refused like
unknown addresses, without being cached as unknown. Mail moves lastMessageAt
and turns a pending mask enabled. Sub-addresses on a mask work.
New crate crates/features (inbuxa-features), AGPL-3.0-only, holding the
tenancy rules. Hooks in common: a tenant's roles and permission lists cap
its people's permissions; a change to a tenant, or to a role a tenant holds,
drops its members' cached permissions; delivery and every other write check
the tenant's maxDiskQuota; usedDiskQuota reads the tenant usage counter.
The default Tenant Administrator role gains sysTenantGet and sysTenantQuery.
- The recovery administrator (INBUXA_RECOVERY_ADMIN, or STALWART_RECOVERY_ADMIN)
is honored only in bootstrap and recovery mode. On a configured server it's
ignored with a startup warning. Before, it was a standing full-admin login
for as long as the variable stayed set.
- The Enterprise upsell error is replaced by "This feature isn't available in
INBUXA yet" for the features still to be rebuilt.
- Workspace warnings: 25 to 0. cargo fix removed the unused imports. The
seven places where Enterprise code used to plug in keep their parameters,
each with an inbuxa: comment naming the rebuild that uses it again. The
antispam test's mock-server imports are back behind pending-rebuild.
Upstream commit: 474dd0229cb20cf513036619781ed97bd8073c3f
Enterprise-only files removed or emptied: 63
Enterprise-only snippets removed: 117 in 50 files
Dangling module declarations removed: 5
Cargo edits turning enterprise off: 14
Verification: clean
Enterprise feature gates left for rebuilt features: 19 in 18 files
Produced by tools/fork/strip.py. The full report is in docs/fork/strip-reports/ on main.
jcoffey-dev