Merge pull request 'SPEC §2.4: allow factual comparisons, never with Stalwart' (#151) from docs/spec-comparisons into main
ci / fork-checks (push) Skipped
ci / build (push) Skipped
github/ci (branch) GitHub Actions
ci / github (push) Canceled after 4m50s

This commit was merged in pull request #151.
This commit is contained in:
jcoffey-dev committed 2026-10-05 23:32:44 +00:00
commit 8a596c44ac
1 file changed
+22 -11
+22 -11
View File
@@ -209,9 +209,9 @@ depends on `store` and can't be called from it (`features/scale-out-storage.md`)
- No "Stalwart" in product names, binaries, images, UI text, packaging or
domains.
- Factual statements are allowed and required: "a fork of Stalwart",
"compatible with Stalwart 0.16 data". Upstream copyright notices stay on
every file they cover.
- Factual statements are allowed and required: "started as a fork of
Stalwart", "compatible with Stalwart 0.16 data". Upstream copyright notices
stay on every file they cover.
- **Identifiers people meet carry the fork's name** (changed 2026-09-22;
this bullet used to keep upstream's). Upstream's JMAP capability for the
registry (`x:`) objects is `urn:inbuxa:jmap:registry`, beside the fork's
@@ -242,14 +242,25 @@ depends on `store` and can't be called from it (`features/scale-out-storage.md`)
- **Public material names it once, as fact, with the mark attributed** (added
2026-09-19). Where the name appears outside the product — the site, release
announcements, documentation — it carries the attribution: Stalwart is a
trademark of Stalwart Labs LLC, and INBUXA is not affiliated with or
endorsed by them. The fork relationship is stated in the provenance or
license section, and the migration path names the server it migrates from,
because an operator searching for it has to find it. The base *version*
belongs with the operator-facing material above — not in taglines, page
titles, hero copy or social previews, where it reads as a source identifier
rather than a fact. No comparison, favorable or otherwise: what INBUXA
offers is stated on its own terms.
trademark of Stalwart Labs LLC, and inbuxa is not affiliated with or
endorsed by them. The lineage is told in the past tense: inbuxa *started as*
a fork of Stalwart and its server *descends from* it; never "built on
Stalwart" or "Stalwart with extras". It is told once, in the license or
about section, and the clean-room provenance lives on one documentation
page that everything else links to. The migration path names the server it
migrates from, because an operator searching for it has to find it. The
base *version* belongs with the operator-facing material above — not in
taglines, page titles, hero copy or social previews, where it reads as a
source identifier rather than a fact.
- **Comparisons: other products yes, Stalwart no** (changed 2026-10-05; this
bullet used to forbid comparison of any kind). Public material may compare
inbuxa with the hosted suites organizations choose between and with other
self-hosted mail stacks, when the comparison is factual, dated, names no
price, and says when the other choice is the better one. Self-hosted peers
are treated with respect. Stalwart is never compared: no editions, no
pricing, no commentary on Stalwart Labs or other forks. The rebuilt features
are described on their own merits, never as the features someone else
charges for.
### 2.5 Packaging