Take multi-tenancy off the roadmap
Cairn OBS is self-hosted, and the way to separate two environments is to run two installations rather than two tenants inside one. Tenancy is the wrong boundary for that, on three counts this repository demonstrates rather than assumes: chwriter.WriteBatch is all-or-nothing across tenants, so one tenant's failure stalls offset progress for every other; CLICKHOUSE_DEFAULT_ACCESS_MANAGEMENT puts every tenant's data behind a single superuser credential, as docker-compose.yml's own comment says; and one binary with one set of migrations moves every tenant together, which is the opposite of what separate environments are for. A whole installation idles at about 1.3 GB, so the sharing buys nothing. The project led with multi-tenant RBAC in the README banner and in PROJECT-SPEC's goal statement. Both now say what it is instead: self-hosted. "Open-core" goes with them -- it was already inaccurate, since CONTRIBUTING states there is no feature gate and no paid tier, and with enterprise/ off the roadmap there will not be one. A second identity provider comes off the list of things standing between this and production-ready. SSO belongs to enterprise/, and a self-hosted deployment is not waiting on it. Terraform's tenant/RBAC resources move from "disclosed future work" to not planned. Nothing is scrubbed from the record. Phase 4 stays shipped, its runbook stays, and its known gaps stay stated -- rewriting that history would contradict the candour the Status section is built on. enterprise/ stays in the tree, AGPLv3 and working, as the answer to a question this project is not asking. Signed-off-by: John Coffey <[email protected]>
This commit is contained in:
+4
-1
@@ -188,7 +188,10 @@ Terraform state; see "`cairnobs_notification_target`'s `secret`
|
||||
attribute" above.
|
||||
|
||||
**Also not built, all real and disclosed, not attempted here:**
|
||||
- Tenant/RBAC resources (`enterprise-auth`'s tenant/membership/grant
|
||||
- Tenant/RBAC resources -- **not planned**, since multi-tenancy came off
|
||||
the roadmap (see the README's "Multi-tenancy is not the plan"). The
|
||||
original accounting stands for anyone who picks it up anyway:
|
||||
(`enterprise-auth`'s tenant/membership/grant
|
||||
surface) -- meaningfully different auth model (offline operator flags
|
||||
today, not a stable REST API a provider could safely drive
|
||||
idempotently -- see `/enterprise/README.md`'s "Bootstrapping a tenant"
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user